WHO’s new HIV guidelines may ‘distract’, warns expert

While government grapples with how to accommodate new World Health Organisation (WHO) guidelines on HIV treatment, which mean over a million extra people are immediately eligible for antiretroviral medicine, a leading AIDS expert has warned that these may be a “distraction”.

The WHO recommended last month that people with a CD4 count of 500 or less should be put on antiretroviral medicine. It also recommended ARVs for all pregnant and breastfeeding women, all children under the age of five, people with tuberculosis or hepatitis B and people with HIV-negative sexual partners.

But Professor Francois Venter says treating all people with CD4 counts of 500 and below, instead of the current CD4 of 350 “is not a priority but a distraction” as most HIV transmission is from people with CD4 counts below 350.

“We need to fix the system and get the core treatment programme right for people with CD4 counts of 350 and less,” says Venter, Deputy Director of the Wits University’s Reproductive Health and HIV Institute.

A CD4 count is the measure of white blood cells per cubic millimetre of blood in a person’s body, with 500 being at the low end of the normal range. The virus attacks the white blood cells first, so a person’s CD4 count gives a good idea of how far the virus has progressed.

“The WHO guidelines presuppose a strong health system, but we have been seeing drug stock-outs and some ARVs in short supply being substituted with others.”

Venter is also concerned of the build-up of toxicity in patients who are put onto the early HIV medicines, such as stavudine, for a longer period.

The Department of Health has accepted the WHO’s proposals, and spokesperson Joe Maila says they are considering ways to implement them.

At present, South Africans with CD4 counts of 350 or less, all pregnant women and children under five are all eligible for ARVs. Government is also poised to recommend ARV treatment for all those co-infected with TB.

“There is a huge benefit for people with HIV negative partners to be on ARVs from earlier on, but the health benefits of treating everyone from CD4 of 500 are based on poor data,” says Venter.

“Most HIV transmission is from people with CD4 counts of under 350. For example, about 85 percent of mother-to-child transmission of HIV is when the mother’s CD4 count is below 350,” says Venter.

“If we treat everyone from CD4 350, we will get most of the transmission prevention benefits as if we treat all those from CD4 500.” – Health-e News Service.

Print Friendly

2 Responses to WHO’s new HIV guidelines may ‘distract’, warns expert

  1. Godwin July 25, 2013 at 1:55 pm #

    Professor, most HIV transmissions happen at higher CD4 counts, around the time of transmission, when viral load is very high. The Gvt is right, people should start HAART at a higher CD4 count, but yes, we need to make sure the logistics are in place first, not to hurry it because WHO said so.

  2. Jay July 29, 2013 at 5:11 pm #

    A recommendation is not an obligation but it allows for putting on treatment people who otherwise would not have had that opportunity. Clearly, in resource-limited settings there are choice to make and doctors are making them everyday.

Developed by LightSpeed

Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contact us

  • PLEASE NOTE: Health-e News is a news service. We are therefore only able to respond to e-mails concerning specific stories or television programmes that we have published or broadcasted. These related comments or suggestions can been addressed to the editor or the relevant journalists. | We are unable to respond to e-mails of a medical nature or queries unrelated to our specific work. Please refer to our resource section for further information.

    Cape Town

    22 Draper Square, Draper Street, Claremont, Cape Town | View on Google Maps | P O Box 23482, Claremont, 7735 | 021 683 8099 | Fax: 021 683 8144

    Johannesburg

    2nd Floor North Tower, 160 Jan Smuts Avenue, Rosebank, Johannesburg | View on Google Maps | PO Box 52428, Saxonwold 2132 | 011 880 0995

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.